Strategic Value of Employee Benefits Programs Instructionsratiff1
Evaluating Corporate Recruiting Plan
Roscoe P. Coltrane
Hazzard County University
Dr. Courtney Hammonds
January 18, 2021
This report examined current and past theory on recruiting strategies and processes to emphasize
the importance and relevancy of effective selection processes for competitive business
organizations. Gatewood, Field & Barrick (2016, p. 36) uses the word “formidable” to indicate
the arduous nature of conceptualizing and developing an effective selection program.
Particularly, the authors as well assert that the difficulty level in developing sound recruitment
and selection processes is compounded when consideration is given to the adherence of certain
laws that impact hiring and selection. This report recognizes the need for effective recruiting
plans as a critical organizational strategy aimed at attracting top quality employees. It also makes
the case that targeted recruiting must have as its foundation processes and programs that strongly
address underrepresented groups in hiring. The report finally recognizes that no recruitment
strategy or plan, whether from the private or public sector can truly be effective or add overall
organizational value if those developing such strategies lack knowledge of how laws affect
selection and hiring.
Evaluate the Merits and Limitations of Recruiting Plan
Selecting and acquiring top talent has never been more important today for organizations
seeking competitive advantage. Thus, the need for an effective recruitment strategy and plan is
essential for acquiring and retaining top talent (Brazeel, 2010, p.1). The overall effectiveness of
the organization’s recruitment plan is even more important when consideration is given to the
need to recruit across levels. Rashmi (2010) believes most organizations will probably have
structured recruitment and selection processes but knowing how the processes are applied across
levels is essential. The processes (or program) may differ in:
o sources of recruitment
o advertisement content
o application methods
o selection methods, and
o closure methods (p. 121).
Understanding the merits and limitations of organizational recruitment plans will increase the
likelihood that HR teams will develop strong recruitment and selection processes.
Recruitment Plan Evaluation – Foxconn
This report assumed that like most major organizations Foxconn is making significant
investments in major new operations. To support this endeavor, they have determined a need
exists for additional employees with specific knowledge, skills, and abilities. Such experience is
needed to meet the demands of high-performing teams. An evaluation of the current recruitment
plan for IT and engineer positions reveals Foxconn’s current plan utilizing college job fairs,
internships, professional organizations, and executive recruitment. The recruitment plan for
administrative and distribution center entails sourcing from local newspapers, point-of-sales
advertising, and internal job referrals. As a result of these findings, this report recommends
eliminating across each plan college job fairs and local newspapers.
As far as IT and engineer positions, they are usually considered high-profile or high
performing positions thus, professional organizations, executive search, and even internships
must remain part of the current recruitment plan. The latter of the elements can also be a cost-
saving measure in terms of salary and benefits. Rockwood and Hermans (2020) also states
“Intern hiring was expected to increase 2.6 percent in 2019 from the previous year” (p. 68). The
authors also made a point that pools of highly motivated interns are available. Each element will
likely continue to be successful and can also be leveraged by the recruitment plan for
administrative and distribution positions.
On the other hand, the likelihood of on-site college job fairs and local newspapers
continuing to be successful are rather slim. With the existing Covid-19 concerns across the
nation, it is easy to speculate that the lack of willingness to participate in such a job fair event,
particularly at rented facilities or on site, exists with both candidates and the hosting
organization. With respect to using local papers as a source for recruiting talent this approach
may be seen a limiting strategy for two reasons. First, there is some research suggesting that
newspapers are no longer a primary sources of information, thus many people are no longer
reading newspapers. It is worth mentioning the following:
The estimated total U.S. daily newspaper circulation (print and digital combined) in 2018
was 28.6 million for weekday and 30.8 million for Sunday, down 8% and 9%,
respectively, from the previous year. Weekday print circulation decreased 12% and
Sunday print circulation decreased 13% (Pew Research Center, n.d., sec. 2).
Based on the overall analysis for this report’s section on evaluating the recruitment plan, a
general recommendation might be that Foxconn leverage the plan elements for the IT and
engineer positions and morph them into the administrative and distribution positions plan.
Recommending Plan for Successful Research-Based Recruiting of Targeted Groups
Organizations evaluate recruiting effectiveness to see how their recruiting efforts
compare with past patterns. They also do so to make comparisons with other organizations.
Recruiting strategies take into consideration a number of EEO and diversity considerations and
therefore the need for HR leaders to address target groups, such as underrepresented candidates
has never been more important.
Recruitment of Targeted Groups: A Brief Analysis
This report contends when organizations apply specific practices aimed at recruiting
targeted groups such approaches tend to make the overall workplace more functionally creative
and innovative (McKay & Avery, 2005, p. 332). The term “targeted groups” takes on different
meanings with respect to the overall goal of recruiting top talent. Target groups could be candidates
with specific expertise and experience regardless of race, color, or national origin. However,
targeted groups may also be candidates that have previously been underrepresented but now the
goal of recruiting is to close the gap between majority and minority representation. To emphasize
the importance of closing selection gaps three underrepresented target groups are worth discussing,
minorities, women, and disabled candidates.
It is important to understand and discuss the topic of diversity in organizations to appreciate
the need to better represent minorities, women, and disabled candidates, especially when seeking
top talent. Diversity simply put is the existence of differences in people (Lussier & Hendon, 2019,
p. 95). When organizations understand the significance of a diverse workplace and its impact on
creativity (thinking uniquely) and innovation (creating new processes), they begin to recognize the
value of minority, women, and disabled worker representation across the organizational landscape.
It is also critical for management and HR teams to understand current legal mandates that impact
policies and practices used to recruit talent including Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), Age
Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), Equal Pay Act (EPA), and Pregnancy Discrimination
Act (PDA] (Gatewood, Field & Barrick, 2016, p. 35).
Recommendations for Targeted Search Success
One recommendation for enabling targeted search success to ensure adherence to
guidelines derived from law and hiring practices is to ensure HR managers remain abreast of
both current and guidance on diversity and inclusion and the previously mentioned laws in this
report. This is especially needed as HR departments seek to modernize and reform assessment
and hiring of job candidates (Federal Register, 2020, para 2). Regular policy reviews and
strategic planning meetings will be beneficial. Another recommendation for enabling targeted
search success to ensure adherence to guidelines derived from law and hiring practices is to
ensure HR teams are knowledgeable of other key laws and current best practice affecting
targeted groups. Joubert (2020, p.11) believes that such understanding of key laws and industry
best practices positions HR to be a more effective business partner when sourcing top talent.
As a final recommendation
As a final recommendation it will be necessary to simply maintain effective internal
management principles around planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. Through these
principles management teams and HR leaders stay abreast of the changing landscape of the
organization but also to their own accountability for avoiding discrimination in hiring and by
targeting groups normally considered underrepresented. Talent acquisition is one of the most
important HR functions in the department and not understanding how prevailing laws impact that
function places the HR team at a disadvantage for adding value to the organization.
Identify Impact of Legal Environment on the Recruiting Process
Gatewood et al, 2016 provides an informative perspective on Federal laws that must be
considered by HR practitioners when formulating strategies to develop recruitment and selection
processes. Some of the laws noted include the civil rights act of 1991, age discrimination in
employment act, Americans with disabilities act, immigration and control reform act, and several
executive orders (p. 107). This report focused on the latter, executive orders in the federal
government, since they are centered on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, handicap, or
age. The primary focus are executive orders 13087 and 13672.
Executive Orders and Impact on Hiring, Recruiting, and Promotion
Executive orders 13087 and 13672 came about due to the need to make more specific
guidance related to Executive Order 11478. In other words, the executive order needed to be
updated to clarify and make additions to current characteristics (race, color, religion, etc.). Thus,
the essentials of orders 13087 and 13672 can be simply summarized as follows:
o Executive Order 13087 Signed in 1998, this order amends Executive Order 11478 to
include sexual orientation.
o Executive Order 13672 Signed in 2014, this order amends Executive Order 11478 and
11246 to include gender identity (Gatewood et al, 2016, p. 110).
The selection of executive orders 13087 and 13672 for this report was important because each
makes clear the apparent need to highlight the terms sexual orientation and gender identity—and
rightfully so. Look no further than the recent Supreme Court ruling that federal civil rights law
recognized to protect gay, lesbian, and transgender workers (de Vogue & Cole, 2020). The
actions by the courts to emphasize such fair treatment is not just beneficial support for
employment candidates in the federal sector, but as well, the private sector.
Finally, it is recommended that federal government agencies ensure adherence to
executive orders derived from law and hiring practices is to ensure department managers remain
abreast of both current and prior executive orders. This is especially needed as these departments
seek to modernize and reform assessment and hiring of federal job candidates (Federal Register,
2020, sec. 3). Regular policy reviews and strategic planning meetings will be beneficial. Just as
critical for agencies and organizations to understand and leverage executive orders so is dealing
with perceived human resource business partner issues derived from legal implications.
HR Issues and Law Implications
There are two issues that immediately come to mind that HR leaders encounter. The first
is clarity of federal laws versus state laws. The second issue derives somewhat from the first and
it centers on challenges and constraints for recruiting.
HR Issues with Federal Vs. State Laws
HR support departments in organizations must be well-versed on both federal and state
laws, especially when they govern how employment processes are applied. “The U.S.
Department of Labor (DOL) administers and enforces more than 180 federal laws. These
mandates and the regulations that implement them cover many workplace activities for about
150 million workers and 10 million workplaces” (DOL, n.d., para 1). The website lists several
laws that impact employment and the laws apply to things like wages and hours, workplace
safety and health, workers compensation, and family and medical leave to name just a few. Lack
of understand and applying these laws to organizational strategies and policies are certain to lead
to HR issues.
HR Issues Due to Organization Challenges/Constraints
Challenges and constraints refer to internal organizational actions that can challenge the
implementation of a sound recruitment process. While there may be many challenges or
constraints, three come to mind and they include (1) budgetary constraints, (2) lack of strategic
acuity by HR teams, and (3) applying laws appropriately (Lussier & Hendon, 2019, pp. 169-
170). At first glance one may ask how do federal or state laws impact these challenges and
First, all internal budgets to support HR activities should always be created to not only
ensure necessary jobs are filled, but they must also be planned around the required tasks HR
assumes to ensure legally administered programs, especially those that are jurisdictional (Lo,
Mackay, & Pio, 2015, p. 335). Second, federal and state laws impact how HR teams
strategically understands the laws and strategically communicates and implements the programs
derived from those laws. Finally, the third constraint flows with, and derives from the second
challenge or constraint. However, extra emphasis must be placed for pay equity and other
programs when organizations operate either nationally (across state borders) or globally.
It is important for businesses and their owners to develop and continue to foster good
recruiting plans in efforts to ensure both organizational success and legal compliance. HR teams
in organizations play a major role in that endeavor as they must effectively attract and retain top
talent. Although administrative and legally mandated tasks are important, HR’s strategic
contribution should also add value to the organization by improving the performance of the
business. As such, improving the performance of the business requires a strategic HR
management approach (Mathis, Jackson, Valentine & Meglich, 2017, p. 47). This means, as
derived from the previous discussion herein, HR must appropriately conceive and implement
recruitment practices and programs that are well within the parameters of federal employment
laws. Planning must also address the “jurisdictional nature” of business operations as
employment laws apply differently across regions and borders.
Brazeel, S. (2010). Recruitment and selection in the near future. POWERGRID International.
May 2010, Vol. 15(5), Special section p1-1. 1p.
de Vogue, A. & Cole, D. (2020). Supreme Court says federal law protects LGBTQ workers from
Federal Register. (2020). Modernizing and Reforming the Assessment and Hiring of Federal Job
Gatewood, R. D., Field, H. S. & Barrick, M. R. (2016). Human resource selection: Eighth
Edition. United States: Cengage Learning.
Lo, K., Mackay, K. & Pio, E. (2015). The HR competency requirements for strategic and
functional HR practitioners. International Journal of Human Resource Management,
Volume 26(18), pps. 2308-2328. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585192.2015.1021827
Lussier, R. N. & Hendon J. R. [a] (2019). Human resource management: functions, applications,
and skill development. Third Edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publishing Company.
Mathis, J., Jackson, J. H., Valentine, S. R. & Meglich, P. A. (2017). Human resource
management. Boston, MA: Cengage Learning.
Mckay, P. F. & Avery, D. R. (2005). Warning! Diversity recruitment could backfire. Journal of
Management. Issue 14, p. 330-336 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1056492605280239
Pew Research Center. (n.d.). Newspaper fact sheet. https://www.journalism.org/fact-
Rashmi, T. K. (2010). Recruitment management: 1st Edition. Mumbai, India: Himalaya
Rockwood, K., & Hermans, A. (2020). Today’s interns are tomorrow’s employees. HR
Magazine. Spring 2020, Vol. 65(1), p 66-73. 6p.