Spa management
cumat1y
Online Discussion Rubric
Levels of Achievement
Criteria Excellent Good Fair Satisfactory Unsatisfactory
Introduction and Article Summary
5 to 6 points ➺ Well-developed introduction; grabs reader’s interest ➺ Thesis statement and position clearly stated
4 to 5 points ➺ Introduction creates interest ➺ Thesis states position
3 to 4 points ➺ Introduction adequately explains background; lacks detail ➺ Thesis states the position, but key elements are missing
2 to 3 points ➺ Introduction is unclear collection of information ➺ Thesis is vague and unclear
1 to 2 points
Critical Analysis
10 to 12 points ➺ Well-developed main points; topic sentences relate directly to thesis ➺ Supporting examples are concrete and detailed ➺ Analysis is developed with an effective point of view ➺ Critical issues are clearly identified, analyzed, and supported
8 to 10 points ➺ Most points relate to thesis, but some lack details ➺ Analysis Includes examples and evidence, but could use more descriptive language ➺ Critical issues are partially identified, analyzed, and supported
6 to 8 points ➺ Most points present, but lack details ➺ Little descriptive language is used ➺ Critical issues are not clearly identified, analyzed, or supported
4 to 6 points ➺ Most points poorly developed ➺ Critical issues are poorly identified, analyzed, or supported
0 to 4 points
Insights for Industry
6 to 8 points ➺ Recommendations, solutions, and/or plans of action provided
5 to 6 points ➺ Recommendations and/or plans of action partially provided
4 to 5 points ➺ Recommendations and/or plans of action inadequate
3 to 4 points
0 to 3 points ➺ Recommendations and/or plans of action not provided
Questions for Audience
5 to 6 points ➺ Provides insightful questions for audience
4 to 5 points ➺ Questions provide some insight for audience
3 to 4 points 2 to 3 points
0 to 2 points
Style and Organization, Spelling and Grammar
5 to 6 points ➺ Logical progression of ideas with a clear structure that enhances the thesis ➺ Transitions are effective and vary throughout the paragraph
4 to 5 points ➺ Logical progression of ideas ➺ Transitions are present, but lacks variety ➺ Writing is clear and sentences have varied structure
3 to 4 points ➺ Organization is clear ➺ Transitions are present at times, but there is very little variety ➺ Writing is clear, but could use a little more sentence variety
2 to 3 points ➺ Writing is not organized ➺ Transitions between ideas are unclear or non-existent
0 to 2 points
Name
Description
Rubric Detail
➺ Writing is smooth, skillful, and coherent ➺ Sentences are strong and expressive with varied structure ➺ Language is consistent and words are well chosen ➺ Punctuation, spelling, and grammar all correct. No errors
➺ Language is consistent ➺ Punctuation, spelling, and grammar mostly correct with few errors
to make the writing more interesting ➺ There are some errors in punctuation, spelling, and grammar
➺ Writing is confusing and hard to follow ➺ Contains fragments and/or run- on sentences ➺ Distracting errors in punctuation, spelling, and grammar
APA References
3.5 to 4 points 3 to 3.5 points 2 to 3 points 1.5 to 2 points
0 to 1.5 points
PrintPrint Close WindowClose Window
View Associated Items